Tuesday, May 9, 2017

Nurses and their allies seek a mandate for a nurse in every school, which they say would improve learning outcomes

Kari Hall, CMA, with a Madison County student
By Melissa Patrick
Kentucky Health News

Putting a full-time nurse in every Kentucky school would not only provide health care, but improve education outcomes, say advocates of the idea.

"We need a nurse in every school because we need to quit thinking about health and education as separate entities, because they are not," said Eva Stone, an advanced-practice registered nurse and co-chair of the school-nurse initiative being mounted by nurses' groups and their allies.

One of their strongest allies is retired educator Terry Brooks, executive director of Kentucky Youth Advocates, who says he is "absolutely convinced that the non-cognitive issues that kids face, like health, have as much to do with their capacity to learn as a teaching method."

Brooks added, "There is only so much blood that you can wring out of a turnip when it comes to teaching methods. You always want great teaching methods, but my goodness, we have been working on that for decades with results that are a whole lot more the same than they are different. So if it is not producing significant change, we've got to look for something else. . . . You are not hearing me say that this is a silver bullet, that, boy, a school nurse is going to fix everything, but I think the presence of a school nurse not only impacts kids' health, but it impacts the kids' capacity to learn."

Those assertions are supported by research, including a recent study that looked at the association between school nurses and academic outcomes of high-school students. "It showed that when there was a nurse in a public high school on a full time, every-day basis, graduation rates were higher, absentee rates were lower and ACT scores were higher," Teena Darnell, assistant professor of nursing at Bellarmine University, said about her research.

"And traveling nurses showed no significance on any level. So if you had a part-time nurse, there was no significant difference on academic performance," said Kathy Hager, a Bellarmine nursing professor and president of the Kentucky Nurses Association.

Hager is also a member of the "Every School Needs a Nurse, Every Day" initiative that is advocating mandates for a full-time nurse in every public school, as recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics.

The National Association of School Nurses supports a ratio of one nurse for every 750 healthy students. This was the recommendation of the pediatrics academy until just last year, when it changed its recommendation to a nurse in every school, saying that "The use of a ratio for workload determination in school nursing is inadequate to fill the increasingly complex health needs of students."

Kentucky has one nurse for every 1,254 students, according to a 2011 KYA report, the latest data available. The Kentucky Department of Education only records nurses hired by school boards (187 this year) and does not include any hired by different funding streams.

Darnell's research found that 42 percent of Kentucky's high schools had a full-time nurse, 37 percent had a part-time nurse and 20 percent of them didn't have one at all. Among all schools, 44 percent had full-time registered nurses; 48 percent had either RNs or licensed practical nurses.

State law requires schools to "make any necessary arrangement" to provide for the immediate health needs of students. Stone said they "do that for the most part, but . . . there is no system of monitoring in place."

When a nurse isn't available, student health services are often provided by school employees who are trained to provide those services. Many students have conditions that need frequent attention.

Out of 655,475 students enrolled in Kentucky's public schools last year, 20,711 were diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactive disorder, 14,054 with allergies, 55,897 with asthma, 1,142 with Type 1 diabetes and 5,259 with a seizure disorder, according to the KDE.

Vicki Williams, RN, Calloway County
Vicki Williams, school-health coordinator and one of three school nurses in Calloway County, which has about 3,400 students, said the school system has about 150 employees who have completed medication training, and others who know certain medical procedures, like blood-sugar testing, taking blood pressure and using g-tubes to the stomach.

And though she is allowed to delegate administration of insulin to other employees, Williams said she isn't comfortable doing that. "That is where I will draw the line," she said. "I will not train anybody to give insulin except myself and any other licensed nurse in my building.”

She said schools have many distractions and "Too much insulin is life threatening, and I don't feel comfortable putting that on somebody who has not had more training than a quick diabetes training after school one day."

Hager didn't question that unlicensed employees can be trained to provide such services, but said what they don't have are the assessment skills of a school nurse. "It takes years of experience to recognize what a person looks like with a low blood sugar reaction," which often occurs with young diabetics, she said.

Nurses could be front-line fighters of big-ticket health items, they say

Stone, who worked as a school nurse for 16 years, passionately argues that school nurses could and should be part of a long-term plan to improve Kentucky's dismal health outcomes by improving the health of its children. But she said she also knows the best way to get educators to pay for a full-time school nurse is to "speak the language of education."

"We can talk about health care if we want, and all of the health care people will agree with what we need to do, but the educators don't have buy in in Kentucky and that is because they don't see the value," with some exceptions, she said.

“I want to be clear in saying that I'm not a proponent of just sticking a body in the building. I want a nurse in every school, and I'm going to fight for that, but I think we have to be intentional about what we are asking for and what we are doing,” Stone said.

For example, she said she would like to see a comprehensive school health system in Kentucky that allows school nurses to be care coordinators for all students' health needs, which would put them "on the front line of every health problem that is a big ticket item for Kentucky."

“We could have a very different outcome for children in our state," she said. Later saying, "But of course that means you have to look at school nurses differently than just putting band-aids on boo boos and checking kids for head lice."

Kentucky ranks in the bottom 10 states in the nation for multiple health indicators in children, such as poor physical and mental health, diabetes, asthma, obesity, poor oral health and substance abuse.

Donna Mazyck, executive director of the National Association of School Nurses, also linked school nurses to education, saying they "provide a critical link between students, health and learning." She said the latest federal education law clearly recognizes the intersection between health and education.

"In the law there is a phrase called 'well rounded education,' -- and what does that mean? That means health education, physical education, as well as all the other core courses," she said. "We believe that students need access to a school nurse every day."

Stone also mentioned the importance of the law, noting that one of its goals is to tackle chronic absenteeism, which school nurses can improve. "If they aren't in school, then they don't learn," she said, adding that students who are chronically absent are often the ones in the achievement gaps.

Nurses can boost attendance, which boosts school revenue

Kentucky's school districts want to keep students in school partly because attendance is part of the formula that determines how much money schools get.

Jenny Sexton, RN, works on attendance with
Jennifer Allen, Madison Southern asst. principal
Jennifer "Jenny" Sexton, the school nurse at Madison Southern High School, went from being a part-time nurse at the high school to full-time this year. She and others are actively working to improve attendance through diligent monitoring and positive outreach to chronically absent students and their parents.

Early results have already shown improvements. Madison Southern improved attendance to 94.32 percent in December 2016 from 93.65 percent last year, which means that 41 more students have been attending school this year, on average. Sexton said the improvements will be greater in the next analysis, because she said daily attendance has been running around 95 or 96 percent.

Michelle Malicote, Sexton's school-health-clinic services manager, said, "We are actually seeing that Ms. Jenny, so-called, generated roughly $7,000 in one month, because she kept so many students sitting in their seats for so many more days."

There are several funding models for school nurses. Most of those Stone mentioned involve some funding from Medicaid, or funding somehow connected to Medicaid. For example, several school districts have contracted with health clinics to provide school nurses and in-school access to clinical care that can be billed to the students' health insurance, which is often Medicaid.

Asked if this initiative needs to be put aside until the Trump administration repeals and replaces Obamacare, she said, "Well, we really ought to wait and see," but said another solution would be for Kentucky to lead a demonstration project "to show what we could do with an intentional school health program -- and then you couldn't argue with the outcomes."

Brooks said, “We are going to have to wait and see, to some degree, how health care shakes down at the federal level. I think federal decisions will have a real impact on whether a door is opened for Kentucky to pursue school-based health, and if that door opens, I hope we walk right through it.”

However, Brooks said he is hearing support from lawmakers and school officials for the idea of putting a nurse in every school, and is optimistic about the likely changes to Medicaid that will give states more autonomy.

"I actually am more optimistic about this as an idea whose time has come than I've ever been," Brooks said. "I believe that the concept has been accepted and I think that the flexibility that we may be getting from the feds would actually enhance rather than be a detriment to this."

Mazyck said community involvement is often needed to secure funding for school nurses. “Creative solutions require communities to rise up and say, 'This is what we need,' and that they value it,” she said. “I don't hear people saying they don't want them. I hear them saying, 'How can we afford them? How can this be sustainable?'"

Brooks said, "I don’t think this is some abstract, theoretical, pie-in-the-sky idea. I think if we as a commonwealth said we are really going to go about the business of making a commitment to school based health, I think there are ways we could figure out flexible, creative, win-win ways to fund that proposition. I cannot imagine a single principal in Kentucky not welcoming a school nurse if funding was available."

This article was produced as part of the Health Care Workforce Media Fellowship of the Center for Health, Media & Policy, New York, N.Y. The fellowship is supported by a grant from the Johnson & Johnson Foundation. Kentucky Health News is an independent news service of the Institute for Rural Journalism and Community Issues, based in the School of Journalism and Media at the University of Kentucky, with support from the Foundation for a Healthy Kentucky.

Price transparency in health care is thwarted by providers and others who want to keep deals secret; crowdsourcing may help

Trudy Lieberman
People seeking information on costs of health procedures are frustrated by the lack of clarity from medical providers. Things are not looking up for Americans seeking health-care price transparency, writes Trudy Lieberman in her latest column for the Rural Health News Service.

True price transparency would allow consumers to evaluate costs and plan for elective procedures or services that aren't covered by their insurance, in order to make informed decisions. Unfortunately, it's not that simple, Lieberman writes. Prices are negotiated, often in secret, between insurance companies, hospitals and doctors. One provider can charge different fees for services according to the type of patient and payment method.

Powerful lobbying interests have prevented health-care price transparency. Ohio passed a law last year to require doctors, hospitals and other health-care providers to disclose prices for their services, "but Gov. John Kasich, the Ohio Hospital Association and other health groups that oppose transparency have stymied implementation," Lieberman reports. "The governor’s budget for next year calls for repealing the law."

Lieberman interviewed patients in Nebraska, South Dakota and California who are “downright angry” and demanding information, she reports. They expressed concerns about hospitals intentionally keeping patients in the dark. A California woman made more than 10 phone calls trying to plan for an outpatient procedure, only to find an expected additional $5,706 on her bill.

Lieberman also spoke with Jeanne Pinder, founder and CEO of ClearHealthCosts. The organization with journalism-based roots seeks to empower people looking for information on medical costs. It gathers from people from all over the U.S. insurance companies' explanations of benefits. Their crowd-sourcing approach to price transparency reveals an inexplicable variety in costs, from hundreds to thousands, and codes for procedures. They use the information to maintain a searchable database that generates price reports by ZIP code and region.

Such information sharing via the internet, with a community approach, could be the key to price transparency, Lieberman ventures. Pinder says the “fix” for public frustration and anger is transparency.

But some caution that knowing prices will not necessarily cut health-care costs. Cost does not always equate with quality, but Americans want more price transparency. One in five have compared costs before seeking treatment, according to a Public Agenda report. And most people think that comparing prices has saved them money.
Public Agenda chart

Poll provides more evidence that heroin use is increasing in Ky.; Chandler calls state's opioid epidemic 'truly shocking'

People in health care and law enforcement know that heroin use in Kentucky has increased, and that the state still has a big problem with prescription opioids. Now a statewide poll shows that Kentuckians at large are more collectively aware of the problems, too.

The latest Kentucky Health Issues Poll found that 17 percent of Kentucky adults know someone who is using heroin, up from 9 percent in 2013 and 13 percent in 2015. It also found that 27 percent of Kentucky adults say they know someone who has abused prescription pain medication. That was within the poll's error margin of plus or minus 2.5 percentage points. The poll was taken Sept. 11 through Oct. 19 for the Foundation for a Healthy Kentucky and Interact for Health, a Cincinnati-area foundation.

A news release from the Foundation for a Healthy Kentucky noted that statistics from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention indicate that heroin use has increased sharply across the U.S. among men and women, most age groups, and all income levels.

Ben Chandler
"The country, and Kentucky in particular, are facing an opioid epidemic that is truly shocking," said Foundation President and CEO Ben Chandler. "Kentuckians are seeing friends and family members struggle with addiction, and the increase in heroin use is particularly alarming. Heroin overdose rates are climbing across the country, and Kentucky is no exception."

The poll showed that Northern Kentucky was the place most likely for adults to report that they had family members or friends who had experienced problems because of substance use. In the eight counties comprising the region, 36 percent reported knowing a friend or family member who had problems due to heroin, and almost 30 percent knew someone who abused prescription pain medications.
While heroin was less of a problem in Western Kentucky, that region appears to be experiencing problems with prescription-drug abuse and methamphetamines; 24 percent of adults there said they knew someone with a prescription-drug problem, and 21 percent knew someone who had a meth problem.

"Kentucky's experience with both prescription and illicit opioid abuse has been more severe and longer-lived than that of most other states," the news release said. "This year, the foundation's Howard L. Bost Memorial Health Policy Forum will focus exclusively on the substance use crisis in Kentucky. The free public forum will take place Monday, Sept. 25, in Lexington."

Monday, May 8, 2017

Life expectancy in 13 U.S. counties declined from 1980 to 2014; eight of them are in one contiguous area of Eastern Kentucky

Map by The Washington Post, based on data from University of Wisconsin Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation
A knot of eight Eastern Kentucky counties (Owsley, Lee, Leslie, Breathitt, Clay, Powell, Estill and Perry) had the greatest decline in life expectancy in the United States from 1980 to 2014.

In other words, babies born in those counties today are expected, on average, to live shorter lives than their parents, based on recent death certificates. That was true in only five other counties: two in Alabama and one each in Oklahoma, Mississippi and Tennessee.

The numbers are in a study by the University of Wisconsin Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, published Monday in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine.

The study blamed the declines in life expectancy on poverty, health risks such as smoking and obesity, physical inactivity, and lack of access to health care.

The greatest decline in the U.S. was in Owsley County, where life expectancy in 2014 was 70.2 years, down from 72.4 in 1980. That made it the lowest in Kentucky and sixth lowest in the nation.

"Owsley County Judge-Executive Cale Turner didn’t seem surprised by the findings," Bill Estep reports for the Lexington Herald-Leader. "He ticked off drags on life expectancy the county faces, including a debilitating drug abuse problem; one of the highest poverty rates in the nation; historic lack of access to health care; and high rates of diabetes. Turner said many county residents received better access to health care in recent years with an expansion of Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act. The law hadn’t been in effect long enough to be measured under the study."

Free journalism workshop will be held June 9 in Cincinnati on covering health care and health in rural America

The Association of Health Care Journalists is hosting a free workshop on covering rural health on June 9 in Cincinnati. The keynote speaker will be Julie Willems Van Dijk, director of County Health Rankings and Roadmaps, an annual measure of vital health factors revealing a snapshot of how health is influenced by where people live, learn, work and play. The registration deadline is May 26.

Five workshops will cover a variety of areas, including "Finding rural health stories: What reporters need to know," featuring Trudy Lieberman, contributing editor of Columbia Journalism Review and Laura Ungar, investigative and enterprise reporter for The Courier-Journal and USA Today. The workshop will moderated by Al Cross, director of the University of Kentucky's Institute for Rural Journalism and Community Issues, which publishes Kentucky Health News.

Another workshop, "Challenges of keeping a rural health workforce," will include Timothy L. Putnam, president and chief executive officer of Margaret Mary Health and Brent Wright, associate dean for rural health innovation at the University of Louisville School of Medicine. The workshop will be moderated by Melissa Patrick, a journalist for Kentucky Health News, which is published by the Institute for Rural Journalism and Community Issues.

Other workshops on the schedule are: "How the battle over health reform is impacting rural residents;" "The geographic divide: Reporting on disparities;" and "Covering the opioid epidemic beyond cities." To register for the event click here.

Sunday, May 7, 2017

Kentucky's food insecurity declines slightly, but remains high in southeast; in 3 counties, rate among children is above 30 percent

Dots are food bank locations. For an interactive map with county data, click here.
The percentage of Kentuckians with an insecure food supply has declined slightly but remains ahead of the national average, with several counties well above the average, according to the latest measurement by Feeding America, which calls itself the nation's largest domestic hunger-relief organization.

Food insecurity by county in Kentucky and nearby states:
light green is up to the national average of 14 percent;
the darkest counties have rates of 30 percent or higher.
The latest calculations, for 2015, showed Kentucky's rate at 16 percent, down slightly from 17 percent in 2014, but still ahead of the national average of 14 percent. The rates ranged from 8 percent in Oldham County to 23 percent in Wolfe County.

The measurements use data from the census, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, food-price data and analysis from Nielsen, and information from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which defines food insecurity as "lack of access, at times, to enough food for an active, healthy life for all household members and limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate foods. Food-insecure households are not necessarily food insecure all the time. Food insecurity may reflect a household’s need to make trade-offs between important basic needs, such as housing or medical bills, and purchasing nutritionally adequate foods."

Southeastern Kentucky's Fifth District has the highest food insecurity rate among the state’s six congressional districts, at 19.2 percent, said a news release from the Kentucky Association of Food Banks. "Children are at a higher risk of food insecurity; 20 percent of Kentucky’s children are food-insecure," the release says. "Three Kentucky counties have childhood food-insecurity rates of 30 percent or higher: Wolfe (32.4 percent); Magoffin (30.7 percent); and Clay (30.2 percent). This represents a decrease from the previous year, when 11 Kentucky counties had childhood food-insecurity rates of 30 percent or higher."

More than a fourth of Kentuckians (27.3 percent) in food-insecure households have incomes above 185 percent of the poverty line, "making them likely ineligible for most federal nutrition assistance programs," the release says.

“Though far too many Kentuckians continue to struggle to put healthful food on the table, we are encouraged by the movement in the right direction on hunger in Kentucky,” said Tamara Sandberg, executive director of the food-bank association. “Kentucky is a leader in the nation for our strong public-private partnerships, such as the Kentucky Department of Agriculture Commissioner Ryan Quarles’s hunger initiative and the Kentucky Legal Food Frenzy sponsored by Attorney General Andy Beshear. We are committed to implementing creative solutions to the problem of hunger until the day when no Kentuckian has to go to bed hungry.”


School lunch rules relaxed: USDA delays lower salt limit, allows 1% milk, lets states exempt schools from whole-grain rule

Lunch at school in Henderson (The Gleaner photo)
Schools won't have to cut salt until 2020, and can serve 1 percent fat milk instead of nonfat milk, and states can allow some schools to serve fewer whole grains, under relaxed nutrition guidelines announced May 1 by U.S. Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue.

The announcement reversed the standards championed by former First Lady Michelle Obama in response to increasing obesity among children, but was welcomed by many school nutrition directors.

Mike Sallee, nutrition coordinator for Elizabethtown Inde­pendent Schools, told The News-Enterprise that he had been trying to figure out how to reduce the amount of sodium in meals to 935 milligrams from 1,230 mg, a “huge challenge” because food producers also would have to adjust to using lower amounts of sodium.

Josey Crew, nutrition director for Hardin County Schools, agreed. “It was kind of getting ridiculous with how they wanted to go,” she said, adding that the new rules might also help discourage food waste.

Crew and Sallee told the Elizabethtown newspaper's Katherine Knott that they are waiting for more guidance from the Kentucky Department of Agriculture on the changes. The new rules allow states to "grant exemptions to schools struggling to meet the whole-grain requirement for the 2017-18 school year," Knott writes. "Currently, all grains served must be whole-grain rich."

The National Parent Teacher Association said it was disappointed in the changes. “One in six adolescents is obese, while one in five faces hunger on a daily basis,” President Laura Bay said in a news release. “Critical progress has been made to provide children with healthier foods in schools. It is important that we build on this progress and do not go backward.”

However, "The changes were supported by the School Nutrition Association, the national organization for school nutrition professionals," Knott notes. "They have lobbied for more flexibility since requirements went into place in 2012."

Crew told Knott that complying with the 100 percent whole-grain requirement initially was difficult, especially for pizza: “To find a whole grain crust that tastes good was hard.” However, food manufacturers adapted, and “Now it tastes good. They figured out a good way to make it.”

Though the regulations are being relaxed, they have been in place for several years and the new offerings are "more accepted by students," Knott reports. "For younger students, it’s all they know when it comes to school lunches, Crew said."

Saturday, May 6, 2017

National survey finds many Americans can't identify mental-health problems, and even some who do are unfamiliar with treatment

By Melissa Patrick
Kentucky Health News

Fewer than half of Americans recognize symptoms of anxiety, and many don't know what to do about it, even when they recognize them. And most don't know that prescription drug abuse is a treatable problem.

These were just some of the findings in a federally funded study conducted by Michigan State University that looked at mental-health literacy around four major issues: anxiety, depression, alcohol abuse and prescription drug abuse. It's timely, since May is Mental Health Awareness Month.

Sheila Schuster
"I think that Kentucky has a poor level of health literacy, period, and I would say probably, as the case is nationally, also a poor understanding of mental-health issues," Sheila Schuster, of the Kentucky Mental Health Coalition, said in a telephone interview. She noted that often, Kentucky adults and children alike, tend to use the catch-all phrase "my nerves are bad" to describe any state of poor mental health.

Participants in the study were asked to read short stories about each of the four issues and then asked questions about the stories. Nearly 4,600 people participated in the national, web-based survey.

It found that 54 percent of the participants were not able to recognize the symptoms of anxiety, while 46 percent could. Those who recognized the symptoms were more likely to recommend professional help over self-help strategies, and were also less likely to feel stigma.

Stigma about anxiety remains strong, with 63 percent of the respondents having some level of stigma toward anxiety and 73 percent of them reporting that this stigma exists in their communities.

Anxiety symptoms include restlessness, fatigue, worry, difficulty in concentration, muscle aches, and changes in sleeping patterns.

The study also looked at depression. Nearly one in five Kentucky adults at some time in their life have been told by a health-care provider that they are depressed, according to polling by the federal Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System. Nationally, 16 million adults reported they had a "major depressive episode" in 2015.

Symptoms of depression include difficulty concentrating, fatigue, hopelessness, insomnia, overeating, undereating, muscle aches and sadness.

Study participants were better able to identify depression than anxiety, with 69 percent of them correctly identifying the condition, half again as much as the percentage who could identify anxiety. Again, those who recognize the symptoms of depression were much more likely to recommend professional help than those who didn't recognize the symptoms.

A recent Kentucky Health Issues Poll found that nearly half of Kentucky adults know someone who has a serious problem with depression and nearly 70 percent of those polled said they knew who to contact for services for treatment.

Asked about stigma from depression, 62 percent of the respondents expressed some level of stigma about the condition and 71 reported some stigma in their communities.

"Stigma toward people with depression is a huge barrier to treatment, as individuals do not discuss their depressive symptoms, and are therefore unable to get the help they need. Almost 60 percent of individuals who have depressive symptoms do not seek treatment," says the report.

Schuster, a retired clinical child psychologist, said fear of being labeled and fear of stigma often keeps individuals from seeking treatment for any kind of mental health care.

"We see that in the local communities, small-town communities where people are reluctant to be seen going into the community mental health center," she said. "If it was just a doctor's office building or a health center where services were co-located, where you could get physical and mental health services, people would probably be more likely to go in."

The study also looked at alcohol abuse and prescription-drug misuse.

More than three out of five respondents (63 percent) were able to identify alcohol abuse, which affects almost 16 million Americans; 37 percent were not able to identify it.

Two-thirds of those who correctly identified alcohol abuse recommended self-help strategies instead of recommending professional help, suggesting that many might not be aware that professional help exists for this condition.

About half (51 percent) of respondents who couldn't identify alcohol abuse recommended professional help, while 35 percent of this group recommended self-help strategies.

Symptoms of alcohol abuse include spending a great deal of time obtaining and using alcohol; failing to fulfill obligations at work, home or school due to alcohol use; and continuing to use alcohol despite its negative impact.

Prescription drug abuse is a huge problem in Kentucky. In the survey, 68 percent could correctly identify it, but nearly one-third couldn't.

Signs of prescription drug abuse include taking higher doses than prescribed, excessive mood swings, changes in sleeping patterns, poor decision-making and seeking prescriptions from more than one doctor.

And like alcohol abuse, those who recognized prescription drug misuse were much more likely to recommend self-help strategies than professional help, whereas those who did not identify the misuse were more likely to recommend professional help than self-help.

"Nearly eight in 10 people don’t recognize prescription drug abuse as a treatable problem," says the release.

"I'm not sure that people really understand what an addiction is, as opposed to thinking well, they just made a bad choice or they aren't right with God, or those kinds of things," Schuster said.

Individual and community stigma for alcohol abuse and prescription drug misuse was about the same, 77 percent for individuals and 80 percent and 82 percent respectively for communities.

"There is more talk about the addiction issues than there has been, so in some ways there is a lot less stigma about say, that person has an opiate addiction or is on heroin," Shuster said. "I'm not sure it's any better on the mental-health side. . . . If you see people who are agitated, very anxious or very depressed, I think people tend to shy away from them. They don't want to engage with them. They don't want to talk about it. So, I'm not so sure that that is any better than it has been."

Mark Skidmore, one of the researchers, said the survey aims to give health officials and policymakers a better understanding of where to target education and prevention efforts for these major societal issues. The study is funded by the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.

Schuster said parents need to start talking to young children about how they react to things and help them learn how to better define their emotions. "We really need to educate our kids as much in health topics, both physical and mental health, as we do on pure education topics," she said.

"It would be really helpful if we developed a curriculum where we [encourage] people to ask questions about their mental health, their spiritual health if you will, their behavioral health as well as about their physical health. . . . [to have a] pretty simple check-list of things to at least acquaint people with some of their symptoms" so they would better know when to get help.

Most primary-care physicians and nurse practitioners, don't ask patients, "How are things with you? What's going on in your life? What kind of stress are you under? How are things now compared to six months ago? What is your outlook for the future?" Schuster said. "I don't think they are taking the time to look at that, and yet we know that I think it's 80 percent of the doctor visits are for symptoms that are much more psychological than organic in nature. We need to focus on the whole person."

Environmental group lists Ky. among top 5 states for number of people affected by violations of safe drinking water regulations

Kentucky is ranked in the top five states for the number of people affected by health-based violations of federal drinking water laws, Erica Peterson reports for WFPL in Louisville, drawing on a report from the Natural Resources Defense Council, an environmental group.

The NRDC identified water systems with at least one reported violation of the Safe Drinking Water Act. Most of the violations involved disinfection byproducts, coliform bacteria, pathogens, nitrates, nitrites, lead and copper. The violations are estimated to affect more than 1.5 million Kentuckians.

“What our review of EPA data found is that nearly 77 million Americans are served by community water systems that have violations,” Erik Olson, NRDC health program director and co-author of the report, told Peterson. “That represents about one in four Americans.”

State officials disagreed with the non-profit’s characterization of violations. In an statement In an emailed statement to WFPL, Energy and Environment Cabinet spokesman John Mura said the safety of drinking water in the commonwealth is a top priority for regulators and that the NRDC report was not based in fact, Peterson reports.

“NRDC’s characterization of public drinking water is irresponsible and does not promote meaningful dialogue regarding the important concerns of safe drinking water and drinking water infrastructure investment,” Mura wrote.

Peterson writes that NRDC's "estimate of violations is lower than the actual figures" in an Energy and Environment Cabinet report, which shows Kentucky water systems had nearly a thousand violations of the federal Safe Drinking Water Act in 2015; and 142 of them, or 14 percent, are listed as resolved. The NRDC says this lack of enforcement is a national trend.

Statewide and county-level data that list the number of people served by each water system and the number of violations is available on the NRDC website on an interactive map. The report notes that most of the drinking water violations occur in rural areas, and "systems serving less than 500 people accounted for nearly 70 percent of all violations and a little over half of all health-based violations."

Most of Kentucky's water violations of the Combined Disinfectants and Disinfection Byproducts rule, which establishes health standards for water systems that add disinfectants, like chlorine, to their water. Adding chemicals to disinfect water has established benefits, but they can react with naturally occurring chemicals in water to create byproducts that can harm human health if not managed properly.

A $500 million program administered by the U.S. Department of Agriculture has been available for infrastructure improvements for rural water systems, and was fully funded in the latest federal spending agreement that goes through September, but its future could be uncertain because President Donald Trump originally eliminated this funding in his budget proposal.

Friday, May 5, 2017

Senate's health bill could vary significantly from House's; process will be a test of McConnell's relationship with Trump

Photo by Mark Wilson, Getty Images
What will the U.S. Senate, led by Kentucky's Mitch McConnell, do with the health legislation that the House sent it Thursday?

"Senate Republicans were in no mood for celebration," like their House colleagues and President Trump did, The Washington Post reports. "Instead, they sent an unmistakable message: When it comes to health care, we’re going to do our own thing."

Republican senators are "driven in part by a sense that the House version made insurance cheaper for young people but costlier for older Americans—an influential, mostly GOP voting bloc," The Wall Street Journal reports. "Among the provisions senators are tackling is one that allows insurers to charge older Americans five times as much as younger people and lets states obtain waivers that could make that disparity even larger."

Larry Levitt, a senior vice president at the Kaiser Family Foundation, which focuses on health issues, told the Journal, “Older people buying their own insurance, especially those with lower incomes, are probably the hardest-hit group under this bill.”

McConnell, as leader of the 52-48 Republican majority, has created a working group of 13 senators, including one who has been his staunchest intraparty foe, Ted Cruz of Texas. “We have people who are conservatives, we have people who are much more moderate,” Cruz told a Texas radio station. “It frankly is the process I think the House of Representatives should have started with, and they didn’t.”

The other Texas senator, top McConnell deputy John Cornyn, told the Post, “It was designed by the leader to be a smaller group of people that represent the different perspectives and points of view in our conference. If that group can get to ‘Yes,’ then [we will] take it to the rest of the conference.”

The Journal reports, "The working group is essentially setting aside the House bill to craft a package they hope can attract at least 50 of the 52 GOP senators and avoid Senate procedural rules that could require 60 votes for passage, given that no Democrats are expected to vote for it."

That may require removal of some parts of the House bill that only set rules for health insurance and have no directly relationship to the federal budget. "Some House Republicans said that if the Senate can pass its own version of the health-care bill, it will face major challenges when it returns to the House and faces wary conservatives," the Journal reports.

President Trump suggested Tuesday that the Senate change its rules to simplify things, but McConnell rejected that out of hand. The bill will be a test of the McConnell-Trump relationship, report Sean Sullivan, Abby Phillip and Paul Kane of the Post.

"It will be as much a make-or-break moment for McConnell as for Trump," they write. "The Senate leader has so far been able to fly below the radar on health care as House Republicans worked through their disagreements before ultimately passing a bill. If he cannot do the same, he is likely to be blamed for the collapse of the effort to fulfill a signature GOP campaign promise."

"McConnell is cool and deliberative while Trump is hot and impetuous. But they have privately developed what people close to them say is a respectful relationship. In the 75-year-old majority leader, Trump, 70, sees a senior player in navigating the ways of Washington, in both age and experience. He views him as someone on his level — or at least more on his level than many other Republicans, including House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.). In some regards, McConnell has become a tutor to Trump. The two men speak regularly, with McConnell initiating some calls to guide the novice president. . . . Part of McConnell’s challenge will be convincing Trump that the methodical pace at which the Senate moves is necessary."

McConnell's working group "began meeting weeks ago, but it wasn’t clear until recently that the House bill would pass. It includes Republicans with varying health-care priorities," the Journal reports. But it doesn't include any women, and the women Republicans include two "whose votes are considered especially difficult to land — Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Susan Collins of Maine."

In a possible change that would have major interest in Kentucky, "Senators are weighing pushing the phaseout of the law’s Medicaid expansion until 2022," instead of 2020, the Journal reports. "There is also some talk about nixing a provision that would change Medicaid funding from its current fixed system" of appropriations based on costs incurred by beneficiaries to a set amount per person.

Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky is among the "wild cards," the Post reports. He told the newspaper, “I think that the House Freedom Caucus was able to make the bill a lot less bad. I think there’s still some fundamental problems that I have with it.”

For a detailed look at the bill from the Post, click here.

Thursday, May 4, 2017

House sends Senate bill that would abolish Medicaid expansion and open door to higher premiums for pre-existing conditions

By Al Cross
Kentucky Health News

The health-care bill passed Thursday by House Republicans would end the expansion of Medicaid in 2020, limit the program's funding after that to a fixed amount per person, and let states allow insurance companies to charge higher premiums to people with pre-existing conditions. On a 217-212 vote, the bill went to the Senate, which undoubdtedly will change it.

About 440,000 Kentuckians get free health care through the 2014 expansion of Medicaid to people with incomes up to 138 percent of the federal poverty line. They would be allowed to stay on the program, which covers a total of 1.4 million people but has a monthly turnover of about 30,000 people going on or off as they qualify or don't qualify. New enrollees wouldn't be allowed.

Harris Meyer reports for Modern Healthcare, "Many if not most of the 31 states that expanded Medicaid to low-income adults likely would end those coverage expansions if Congress ultimately approves the House Republican healthcare reform bill passed Thursday, state policy experts say."

The Republican governors of Ohio, Michigan, Arkansas and Nevada in a letter to House and Senate leaders that the bill “provides almost no new flexibility for states, does not ensure the resources necessary to make sure no one is left out, and shifts significant new costs to states,” Kaiser Health News reports. “That pushback has also created doubts in the minds of some GOP senators.”

In debate about the bill, coverage of pre-existing conditions got more attention. An estimated 1.8 million Kentuckians, out of a population of 4.4 million, have some sort of pre-existing medical condition, according to calculations by the Center for American Progress, a liberal or progressive advocacy group, and cited by Kentucky supporters of Obamacare.

To waive coverage of pre-existing conditions, the state would have to show that doing so would help the insurance market and would have to create a high-risk pool for people with such conditions. Experts say such pools usually fail to provide adequate or affordable coverage because they require heavy government subsidies.

Rep. Brett Guthrie
“There are some estimates that very few states, if any, would go through the waiver process,” Rep. Brett Guthrie of Bowling Green, one of four Kentucky representatives who voted for the bill, told Terry Meiners of Louisville's WHAS Radio on Wednesday. “If people want to go down that waiver process, that's something that governors and state legislatures will have to answer to their citizens.” Guthrie worked on the bill as vice chair of the health subcommittee of the House Ways and Means Committee.

The bill, titled the American Health Care Act, failed to secure enough votes to reach the floor in March and was tweaked to win support, first from strong conservatives and then from more moderate Republicans.

Strongly conservative Rep. Thomas Massie of Vanceburg, one of 20 Republicans who voted against it, said on Twitter, “The AHCA is like a kidney stone; the House doesn't care what happens to it, as long as they can pass it.”

The other Kentuckian voting no was Rep. John Yarmuth of Louisville, the only Democrat in the state's delegation. He said after the vote, “This bill weakens healthcare protections for most Americans and leaves families worse off. I hope people will continue to make their voices heard and communicate their discontent to their senators as this irresponsible legislation moves forward.”

In a floor speech before the vote, Yarmuth said, “The question every member of Congress should be asking themselves today is, who in the world is better off because of today's bill? . . . Certainly corporations and millionaires, who will see more than a trillion dollars in tax cuts from this bill. And, at least in their minds, a few Republican members who are so desperate for some type of political victory they are willing to risk the health and well-being of their constituents to ram through a bill without hearing, analysis, or most alarmingly, any sense of morality.”

Rep. Harold "Hal" Rogers of Somerset, the senior member of the Kentucky delegation, said passing the bill was the responsible thing to do because the health-insurance system created by the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act is breaking down. Almost half of Kentucky's counties have only one insurance company offering federally subsidized policies under the law.

Rep. James Comer of Tompkinsville said the bill would “allow states to better manage their unsustainable Medicaid programs, and repeal job-killing taxes and regulations, while still protecting people with pre-existing conditions.”

Rep. Andy Barr of Lexington said voting for the bill fulfilled his promise to “vote to repeal this broken law and replace it with reforms that will actually lower costs and expand access to care through patient-centered, market-based reforms.”

The bill is "making major dents in large portions of the current law but not outright repealing it," The Washington Post reported. "The bumpy, months-long process that led to Thursday’s vote also violated some of the GOP’s own promises on how they would govern. The measure proceeded without the benefit of an analysis from the Congressional Budget Office of its cost and impact on insurance coverage, and it did so after many Republicans openly acknowledged that they hadn’t read the bill. President Trump also promised 'insurance for everybody,' which the measure will not achieve." The 20 Republicans who voted no were "a mix of ardent conservatives upset that the bill didn’t fully repeal Obamacare and members from suburban swing districts worried about the political fallout."

Insurance companies and other health lobbies, such as the American Medical Association, objected to the bill, and its prospects in the Senate are guarded, the Post reports.

Evaluation of Foundation for a Healthy Kentucky's 6-year public-policy initiative offers lessons for other health philanthropies

An independent evaluation of a six-year Foundation for a Healthy Kentucky initiative offered some useful lessons that can be applied to other philanthropic organizations that work on population health, the foundation said in a news release.

The study, conducted by the Center for Community Health and Evaluation, looked at the foundation's $7 million "Promoting Responsive Health Policy" initiative, which focused on ensuring a smooth implementation of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and passing a statewide smoke-free law. The initiative began in 2012.

"Intervening state and federal elections shifted the political environment and state legislative priorities," the study report said. "The new governor proposed significant changes in how the ACA would work in Kentucky and it became clear that a statewide smoke-free law was far less likely to pass by the end of the initiative," says the release. Republican Gov. Matt Bevin, elected in 2015 to succeed Democrat Steve Beshear, has said smoking bans are a local issue.

The foundation's initiative also focused on improving children's health and strengthening local public health. The evaluation thoroughly examined how the foundation addressed each of its priorities, evaluated its interactions with its grantees, and issued a report that includes lessons to inform the field of health philanthropy. They include:
  • Clearly identify policy priorities and understand the trade-offs between specific and broad policy goals. Too broad a goal may limit impact because it spreads resources too thin and makes it hard to develop a "fully cohesive grantee cohort."
  • Make your role as funder clear. Ensure that everyone involved in your organization understands their role in advancing policy.
  • Build flexibility into the grant structure. Consider a variety of grant strategies to inform and influence policy at multiple levels, allowing for some flexibility to allow grantees to respond to changes in the political environment.
  • Build awareness of the broad spectrum of strategies needed. Use a developmental evaluation tool to identify and map your strategy. "The foundation's initiative included grants to advocacy organizations, as well as to nonprofit media outlets to increase coverage of health policy issues; other strategies included targeted research on the impact of policy changes and convenings that brought together diverse groups to align their goals," says the release.
  • Consider long-term grants to build capacity. "The foundation gave one-year grants renewable for up to five years, and allowed mid-year adjustments, to enable grantees to build their own infrastructure and skills so they could be more effective, both during the grant period and beyond," says the release.
Under the initiative, the foundation provided grants to: Kentucky Voices for Health, an umbrella group of organizations supporting federal and state health reform; the Kentucky Equal Justice Center; the Kentucky Center for Smoke-free Policy at the University of Kentucky College of Nursing; the Kentucky Population Health Institute; Kentucky Youth Advocates; Louisville Public Media; Kentucky Educational Television; Kentucky News Connection, part of the Public News Service; and the UK School of Journalism and Media's Institute for Rural Journalism and Community Issues, to publish Kentucky Health News.

In addition, the foundation commissioned a study assessing the implementation of the ACA in Kentucky. The cost of the initiative, including grants, staff support, programs, conferences, training and research, totaled $7,035,101. Click here for a copy of the report.